Market observations retain their individual dates and statuses. This is dated research, not a live price feed.
Energy / natural gas · Hold one March gas short and pass on addingMarch Henry Hub winter premium
The $2.396 cover offer is below both the $2.405 entry and the EIA March cash projection. The earlier February forecast still favors holding. A new comparison of down Mondays produces a much smaller benefit, which can disappear when a stop intervenes.
MNGH27 · intraday · November 16 March NYMEX micro offer to cover the short, USD/MMBtu.
Decision review
Version 3Evidence: Nov 16, 2026, 5:17 a.m. Toronto · Record added: Nov 16, 2026, 5:25 a.m. Toronto
Hold one March gas short and pass on adding
The $2.396 cover offer is below both the $2.405 entry and the EIA March cash projection. The earlier February forecast still favors holding. A new comparison of down Mondays produces a much smaller benefit, which can disappear when a stop intervenes.
MNGH27
Payoffs, assumptions and sensitivities
Managed trade outcomes
| Exit illustration | Net return on entry margin / P&L | Change vs closing now | Original budget R |
|---|---|---|---|
| Target | N/A on entry margin · Not estimated | Not estimated | An explicit exit price is needed for every contract leg. |
| Stop | -105.10% on entry margin · -$1,003.00 | -$1,004.00 | -0.801R |
| Adverse gap | -178.45% on entry margin · -$1,703.00 | -$1,704.00 | -1.360R |
Managed-strategy expected payoff: not estimated. Target-first, stop-first and time-exit probabilities have not been estimated. Stops and targets use observed prices; actual gaps may differ from the illustration.
Current net open P&L: +$5.50. Closing at the recorded mark after exit costs: +$1.00. Initial risk budget: $1,251.75. Original entry margin: $954.32 (sourced initial). R uses the initial budget and does not reset when a position loses money.
Planned trade exit: Feb 12, 2027, 4:00 p.m. Toronto. MNGH27 last-trade date bound 2027-02-23. Net-from-entry results cover the shown size and exclude earlier closed slices. Exit calculations include adverse tick rounding and commissions. Future prices use the recorded currency conversions unless an explicit scenario conversion is supplied.
End-date price forecast
Forecast date: Feb 12, 2027, 4:00 p.m. Toronto. Assumptions dated: Nov 15, 2026, 8:23 p.m. Toronto. Historical decline: 16.67%; Historical middle: 16.67%; Historical rally: 16.67%; EIA cash anchor: 50%. Give half the probability to the November EIA March spot forecast as a February futures-mark proxy. Spread the other half evenly over all 32 March winters, 12 low-price winters, seven steep January/March winters and three meeting both conditions. Observations overlap. Group weighted historical returns in equal thirds and apply to the $2.405 study reference. The observed indicative settlement clock differs from the 16:00 exit.
| End-date scenario | Weight | Reference prices | Net return on entry margin / P&L | Forward net P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Historical decline | 16.67% | MNGH27 1.73 | 69.89% on entry margin · +$667.00 | +$661.50 |
| Historical middle | 16.67% | MNGH27 2.181 | 22.63% on entry margin · +$216.00 | +$210.50 |
| Historical rally | 16.67% | MNGH27 2.889 | -51.55% on entry margin · -$492.00 | -$497.50 |
| EIA cash anchor | 50% | MNGH27 2.423 | -2.72% on entry margin · -$26.00 | -$31.50 |
Weighted result from entry: 5.47% on entry margin · +$52.17. Forward from the mark: +$46.67. Holding versus closing now: +$51.17.
These end-date scenarios assume holding without an earlier exit. Their weights are analyst judgments; they are not probabilities of reaching the target or stop first.
| Sensitivity to the end-date model | Forward net P&L |
|---|---|
| Move 5 percentage points from best to worst payoff | -$11.28 |
| Move 10 percentage points from best to worst payoff | -$69.23 |
| Double future exit friction | +$42.17 |
Shared calculation: $4.50 future exit friction.
Next decision
Will the balance weaken beyond the shoulder-season relief already in the curve?
Evidence to watch
Review the winter curve at 08:00 Toronto, holiday-delayed positioning this afternoon, and Thursday storage.
Review point
Nov 16, 2026, 8:00 a.m. Toronto
If the evidence changes
Cover if the balance or $3.40 stop invalidates the short. Retain February 12 at 16:00 Toronto as the time exit.
Evidence and price reasoning
Market expectation
January near $3.494 and March near $2.393 price substantial shoulder-season relief. The April standard last was $2.345.
ATG’s differing view
The conditional history still leaves room for March to weaken. The current January–March premium is outside the historical test range, reducing confidence in the magnitude.
Supporting evidence
The $2.396 cover offer is below both the $2.405 entry and the EIA March cash projection. The earlier February forecast still favors holding. A new comparison of down Mondays produces a much smaller benefit, which can disappear when a stop intervenes.
Strongest counterargument
The three joint cheap/steep observations averaged a 3.19% gain. A record short position and lower salt storage can amplify a squeeze.
Price assumptions
Matched November entries in the March standard future and February exit settlements. One micro represents 1,000 MMBtu. EIA November 10 release and workbook, CFTC November 3 positions, and closed-window November to February futures comparisons.
Portfolio contribution
Another cold shock could hurt the diesel short and the gas short together. Cap the position at one micro.
Economic research horizon: 2027-03-15. Forecast scoring date: Feb 12, 2027, 4:00 p.m. Toronto. A trade exit does not end the forecast evaluation.
Decision history (3 versions)
- Version 1 · Nov 15, 2026, 8:23 p.m. Toronto · Enter one short March Micro Henry Hub contract
- Version 2 · Nov 16, 2026, 12:14 a.m. Toronto · Hold one short March gas micro
- Version 3 · Nov 16, 2026, 5:17 a.m. Toronto · Hold one March gas short and pass on adding
Entry conditions
Entered one March micro short at $2.405/MMBtu at 20:31 Toronto. The live bid was $2.406 and the simulation charged one adverse tick.
Target framework
Unspecified
Fundamental invalidation
Exit if winter weather, LNG or sustained storage draws invalidate the expected March easing.
Stop and risk limitation
$3.400/MMBtu; gap stress $4.100.
Strongest counterargument
The three joint cheap/steep observations averaged a 3.19% gain. A record short position and lower salt storage can amplify a squeeze.
Next catalyst
Compare Thursday storage and changes to January and February balances. Exit on a confirmed erosion of the supply cushion or the $3.40 risk limit.
Roll and delivery
Close February 12 at 16:00 Toronto, ahead of the holiday and the February 23 final trading date. No delivery or roll.
Market evidence
One NYMEX micro represents 1,000 MMBtu. Its original $954.32 entry margin and $1,251.75 buffered risk budget remain the denominators for the held lot.
Expected return: interpretation
One whole package, gross initial margins with no spread credit.
Source references
- Contract valuation and market data
- Published initial margin
- CME micro specification
- November EIA Short-Term Energy Outlook
- EIA March futures history
- CFTC managed-money positions
- November 2026 forecast tables
- November release
- CPC 8–14 day forecasts
- EIA storage
- EIA November forecast workbook
- EIA historical NYMEX curves
- November 16 gas-weighted weather update
How the view evolved
- Hold one March gas short and pass on adding — The $2.396 cover offer is below both the $2.405 entry and the EIA March cash projection. The earlier February forecast still favors holding. A new comparison of down Mondays produces a much smaller benefit, which can disappear when a stop intervenes.
- Hold one short March gas micro — The cover offer is $2.417 against a $2.405 entry. The historical winter decline still warrants one micro. Low-priced winters give a small and unstable gain through Thursday; a second short would deepen exposure to a cold-weather squeeze.
- Enter one short March Micro Henry Hub contract — A 47% January premium and a cheap March contract make a broad winter gas short dangerous. A March-only test gives a small positive net payoff after anchoring half the distribution to the government’s cash forecast. Limit the sale to one micro.