Market observations retain their individual dates and statuses. This is dated research, not a live price feed.
Agriculture · Avoid buying March cocoa against MayMarch cocoa against May
New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
CCH27 · vendor_close · carried observation · IBKR delayed exact ICE daily Last bar close. Date is the trading session. Exchange settlement unverified.; CCK27 · vendor_close · carried observation · IBKR delayed exact ICE daily Last bar close. Date is the trading session. Exchange settlement unverified.
Decision review
Version 2Evidence: Nov 15, 2026, 8:23 p.m. Toronto · Record added: Nov 15, 2026, 8:33 p.m. Toronto
Avoid buying March cocoa against May
New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
CCH27 / CCK27 · proposed study, no position opened
Payoffs, assumptions and sensitivities
Managed trade outcomes
| Exit illustration | Net return on entry margin / P&L | Change vs closing now | Original budget R |
|---|---|---|---|
| Target | N/A on entry margin · Not estimated | Not estimated | An explicit exit price is needed for every contract leg. |
| Stop | -0.95% on entry margin · -$234.00 | Not estimated | -0.824R |
| Adverse gap | -1.57% on entry margin · -$384.00 | Not estimated | -1.352R |
Managed-strategy expected payoff: not estimated. Target-first, stop-first and time-exit probabilities have not been estimated. Stops and targets use observed prices; actual gaps may differ from the illustration.
Current net open P&L: Not estimated. Closing at the recorded mark after exit costs: Not estimated. Initial risk budget: $284.00. Original entry margin: $24,527.30 (sourced initial). R uses the initial budget and does not reset when a position loses money.
Planned trade exit: Nov 16, 2026, 1:30 p.m. Toronto. CCH27 last trade 2027-03-15; CCK27 last trade 2027-05-13. Net-from-entry results cover the shown size and exclude earlier closed slices. Exit calculations include adverse tick rounding and commissions. Future prices use the recorded currency conversions unless an explicit scenario conversion is supplied.
End-date price forecast
Forecast date: Nov 16, 2026, 1:30 p.m. Toronto. Assumptions dated: Nov 13, 2026, 4:19 p.m. Toronto. Nearby sells off: 28.33%; Little change: 47.78%; Nearby outperforms: 23.89%. Equal weight on the broad and discounted starting samples is a judgment. Grouped means preserve the weighted average. The comparison applies recorded weekend moves to Friday’s close, holding May fixed for the illustration.
| End-date scenario | Weight | Reference prices | Net return on entry margin / P&L | Forward net P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nearby sells off | 28.33% | CCH27 5,258.745098; CCK27 5,334 | -0.59% on entry margin · -$144.00 | Not estimated |
| Little change | 47.78% | CCH27 5,268.116279; CCK27 5,334 | -0.18% on entry margin · -$44.00 | Not estimated |
| Nearby outperforms | 23.89% | CCH27 5,276.465116; CCK27 5,334 | 0.15% on entry margin · +$36.00 | Not estimated |
Weighted result from entry: -0.22% on entry margin · -$53.22. Forward from the mark: Not estimated. Holding versus closing now: Not estimated.
These end-date scenarios assume holding without an earlier exit. Their weights are analyst judgments; they are not probabilities of reaching the target or stop first.
| Sensitivity to the end-date model | Proposed-entry net P&L |
|---|---|
| Move 5 percentage points from best to worst payoff | -$62.22 |
| Move 10 percentage points from best to worst payoff | -$71.22 |
| Double future exit friction | -$84.00 |
Shared calculation: $30.78 future exit friction.
Next decision
Do local delivery bids confirm a shortage despite growth in US warehouse stocks?
Evidence to watch
No entry signal from these weekend observations.
If the evidence changes
Avoid until a new physical change gives a stronger transmission to the US delivery spread.
Evidence and price reasoning
Market expectation
Friday March traded $67/t below May, versus $54 on Thursday. December traded $144/t below March. New York prices reward carrying beans into later delivery.
ATG’s differing view
Flooded roads in Côte d’Ivoire can delay beans without destroying them. US stock accumulation insulates nearby US delivery from an immediate scramble.
Supporting evidence
New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
Strongest counterargument
Road disruption and renewed European processing demand can bid nearby beans ahead of deferred delivery.
Price assumptions
Actual same-contract Friday-to-Monday close changes from 45 three-calendar-day weekends since November 2025. Ten started with a discount of at least $50/t. Equal weight on each sample, grouped by change; May fixed at $5,334 for decomposition.
Portfolio contribution
Little direct overlap with gold or fuels. A physical warehouse squeeze or gap still creates outright-sized leg risk.
Economic research horizon: 2027-03-15. Forecast scoring date: Nov 16, 2026, 1:30 p.m. Toronto. A trade exit does not end the forecast evaluation.
Decision history (2 versions)
- Version 1 · Nov 13, 2026, 4:19 p.m. Toronto · Avoid buying March cocoa against May
- Version 2 · Nov 15, 2026, 8:23 p.m. Toronto · Avoid buying March cocoa against May
Entry conditions
One pair tested at the November 13 closing discount of $67 per metric tonne. No order.
Target framework
Unspecified
Fundamental invalidation
A widening through the observed September extreme of −$78/t under rising US inventories.
Stop and risk limitation
Study stop −$85/t, beyond the prior −$78 extreme.
Strongest counterargument
Road disruption and renewed European processing demand can bid nearby beans ahead of deferred delivery.
Next catalyst
West African weekend arrivals and Monday New York cocoa close.
Roll and delivery
End at the November 16 New York close, before March first notice on February 22. No roll.
Market evidence
One standard leg is 10 metric tonnes. A $1/t tick is $10 per leg.
Expected return: interpretation
Study reserves $12,263.65 per leg of original initial margin without a spread offset.
Source references
- ICE warehouse workbook
- Total warehouse stock, reported November 13
- European Cocoa Association Q3 grindings
- ICE contract terms
- ICE expiry dates
- IBKR ICE margins
- IBKR daily history
How the view evolved
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.
- Avoid buying March cocoa against May — New York cocoa rose outright while March lost another $13/t to May. US warehouse stocks increased by 21,244 bags. Earlier weekends with a wide March discount did not deliver enough tightening to cover the two-leg costs. Avoid the calendar purchase.